For a basic rate taxpayer the two methods reach the same place by different routes.
How each method works
Net pay takes the full contribution from gross pay, so taxable pay falls and you get relief at your highest rate straight away. Relief at source takes it from pay after tax, and the scheme claims 20% back from HMRC and adds it to the pot, so £80 from you becomes £100 in the pension. Salary sacrifice is a third method, where you give up gross salary and the employer pays it in, and it is the only one of the three that saves National Insurance.
Where the two actually differ
For a basic rate taxpayer the end result is the same. Two groups come out differently. Take someone part-time on less than the £12,570 Personal Allowance who pays in £80. Under relief at source the pot gets £100. Under net pay it gets £80, because there was no tax to relieve.
The other group is higher and additional rate taxpayers. Under net pay the higher relief comes automatically, because taxable pay falls before tax is worked out. Under relief at source only 20% comes automatically, and you claim the remaining 20% or 25% through a tax return or by contacting HMRC. That claim is the one that gets missed if nobody tells you about it, which makes this the group for whom the method matters most.
How to tell which one you are on
The payslip usually gives it away. Your scheme documents state the method too.
- If your taxable pay is lower than your gross pay by the contribution amount, you are on net pay.
- If the contribution is taken after tax and your taxable pay matches your gross pay, you are on relief at source.
- If your gross pay itself is reduced and National Insurance falls too, it is salary sacrifice.
What this answer does not decide
This is educational guidance on how UK pay and tax work. It does not decide payroll correctness, HMRC treatment, lender approval, benefit entitlement or employment rights, and it is not regulated financial advice. Where a figure matters, check it against your payslip, your HMRC account, or the official guidance linked above.
Last updated 2026-11-01. Maintained by Sean Elsmore. Rates last checked against GOV.UK on 2026-09-02. Estimates are for planning, not financial advice, and should be checked against official records where the decision matters.