HMRC rates2026/27 PAYE defaults

Why is my payslip tax so high?

It depends whether the tax is high in one month or in every month.

The short answer

If one month jumped and the next went back to normal, look for a bonus or overtime going through that payslip. If every payslip is high, look at the tax code: an emergency code after a new job, or a code HMRC has lowered to collect something, takes more from the same pay. On £3,000 a month, an emergency 0T M1 code takes £600 of Income Tax where 1257L takes about £390.

Where the tax code appears on a payslip A payslip diagram highlighting a 1257L tax code field and PAYE Income Tax deduction row. EXAMPLE ONLY Example Employer Ltd Employee: Alex Example Pay date: 31 May 2026 | Pay period: Month 2 Tax code 1257L Gross pay £3,333.33 Taxable pay £3,333.33 PAYE Income Tax -£414.20 National Insurance -£188.64 Pension -£166.67 Student loan -£58.00 Net pay £2,505.82 Employer pension contribution shown separately where provided by payroll Where the tax code appears on a payslip A payslip diagram highlighting a 1257L tax code field and PAYE Income Tax deduction row. EXAMPLE ONLY Example Employer Ltd Employee: Alex Example Pay date: 31 May 2026 Pay period: Month 2 Tax code 1257L Gross pay £3,333.33 Taxable pay £3,333.33 PAYE Income Tax -£414.20 National Insurance -£188.64 Pension -£166.67 Student loan -£58.00 Net pay £2,505.82 Employer pension contributionshown separately whereprovided by payroll
Fictional payslip diagram highlighting the tax-code area. Real labels vary by employer and payroll provider.

Why a payslip can differ

Why a payslip can differ
Tax codeHMRC tax-code changes, K codes, BR/D codes, or emergency markers can change PAYE deductions.
Cumulative basisPayroll works on the year so far, or on one period for a Week 1, Month 1 or non-cumulative code, so a payslip can differ from an annual estimate.
Pension methodRelief at source, net pay and salary sacrifice can affect taxable pay and take-home pay differently.
Payroll timingBonus, overtime, arrears, refunds, cut-off dates and corrections can all move a single payslip.

How to tell from the payslip

Read the tax code first, because it sets how the rest of your pay is taxed, then taxable pay for the period. Between them they point to one of these.

  • The code ends W1, M1 or X, or the payslip says NONCUM: this is an emergency code, usually because a new employer did not have your previous pay and tax details.
  • The code is 0T: no allowance is being given at all. On a second job, BR or D0 taxes every pound at a single rate because your allowance is being used in your main job.
  • The number in the code is lower than it was, or the code starts with K: HMRC is collecting something through your wages, often taxable benefits or tax underpaid in an earlier year.
  • The code has not changed but taxable pay is up: a bonus, overtime, arrears or holiday pay has gone through this period. On £3,000 a month and 1257L, a £1,000 bonus adds £200 of Income Tax to that month's payslip, which is the basic rate on the bonus.
  • The code and taxable pay are both unchanged and the tax is still different: this points to a payroll correction or the reversal of a refund, and payroll is the one who can say which.

£3,000 a month on an emergency code

At the 2026/27 rates for England, Wales and Northern Ireland, 1257L gives Income Tax of about £390 a month. On 0T M1 no allowance is given, so the same pay is taxed from the first pound and the Income Tax is £600, about £210 more each month. National Insurance is about £156 on either code. These are one month on its own from HMRC's monthly tables, and a cumulative code can differ by pence depending on the tax month. A code such as 1257L M1 is different: on level pay from the start of the tax year it takes within pence of 1257L. It costs more if you start part-way through the year, because each month only gets that month's share of the allowance, where a cumulative code would also give you the part you had not used.

How it gets put right

After a new job, giving your new employer your P45 is the usual first step, and HMRC can take up to 35 days from your start date to update the code. If you have paid too much tax over the year you can get a refund. PayBreakdown's payslip checker works out what your pay and tax code should have produced, but it cannot access HMRC or payroll records and it cannot decide that a payslip is wrong.

What this answer does not decide

This is educational guidance on how UK pay and tax work. It does not decide payroll correctness, HMRC treatment, lender approval, benefit entitlement or employment rights, and it is not regulated financial advice. Where a figure matters, check it against your payslip, your HMRC account, or the official guidance linked above.

Official sources

GOV.UK: how Income Tax is paidGOV.UK: tax codesGOV.UK: payslipsGOV.UK: PAYE forms P45, P60 and P11D

Frequently asked questions

Does high tax always mean payroll made a mistake?

No. Usually payroll is applying the code it was given. The code can still be out of date, which is why the code is the first thing to read.

Can a bonus make tax look too high?

It lands in one payslip, so the tax line jumps that month and goes back down the next. On a cumulative code that is the tax on the extra pay, and it is not an over-deduction.

Last updated 2026-11-02. Maintained by Sean Elsmore. Rates last checked against GOV.UK on 2026-09-02. Estimates are for planning, not financial advice, and should be checked against official records where the decision matters.