The short answer
Pension comes off before tax under net pay and salary sacrifice, and after tax under relief at source, where your provider adds basic-rate relief to the pot instead. On £44,000 with £150 a month going in, Income Tax is £5,926 under the first two and £6,286 under relief at source.
£150 a month on £44,000
The table is a 2026/27 estimate for England, Wales and Northern Ireland on a standard tax code, with no student loan. Under relief at source your £1,800 a year becomes £2,250 in the pot, so that lower take-home buys more pension. The other two put in £1,800.
Telling which one your payslip uses
Make this check first, because a calculator set to the wrong method has the wrong Income Tax and the wrong take-home. On a plain payslip, put gross pay beside taxable pay for the same period. If they differ by the contribution, that is net pay. If they match and pension is still a deduction, that is relief at source. Under salary sacrifice gross pay itself is below your contract salary, and your employer pays the pension.
If you pay higher-rate tax under relief at source, the provider's claim only covers the basic rate, and you claim the rest through Self Assessment.
What this answer does not decide
This is educational guidance on how UK pay and tax work. It does not decide payroll correctness, HMRC treatment, lender approval, benefit entitlement or employment rights, and it is not regulated financial advice. Where a figure matters, check it against your payslip, your HMRC account, or the official guidance linked above.
Last updated 2026-11-01. Maintained by Sean Elsmore. Rates last checked against GOV.UK on 2026-09-02. Estimates are for planning, not financial advice, and should be checked against official records where the decision matters.